Aquaman 2, the highly anticipated follow-up to the 2018 blockbuster Aquaman, has finally hit the theaters, but not without controversy. The movie, which stars Jason Momoa as the half-human, half-Atlantean hero Arthur Curry, has received mixed reviews from critics and fans alike, who have praised its visual spectacle and action, but criticized its messy plot and poor performance of Amber Heard as Mera.
The movie, directed by James Wan, who also helmed the first installment, tries to pack too much into one story, resulting in a confusing and predictable narrative that spans multiple locations, villains, and subplots. The movie features Arthur’s conflict with his half-brother Orm (Patrick Wilson), who seeks to unite the seven underwater kingdoms and wage war on the surface world, as well as his quest to find the mythical Trident of Atlan, which grants him the power to rule the seas. Along the way, he faces threats from the pirate Black Manta (Yahya Abdul-Mateen II), who seeks revenge for his father’s death, and the ancient sea monster Karathen, voiced by Julie Andrews.
The movie also attempts to develop the romance between Arthur and Mera, his love interest and ally, who helps him on his journey. However, many viewers have expressed their dissatisfaction with the casting of Amber Heard, who has been embroiled in a legal battle with her ex-husband Johnny Depp over allegations of domestic abuse. Some fans have even petitioned to have her removed from the movie, citing her lack of chemistry with Momoa and her poor acting skills.
Despite the flaws, Aquaman 2 does offer some redeeming qualities:
- The stunning visuals and the impressive action scenes, which showcase the underwater worlds and the mythical creatures that inhabit them.
- The charisma and humor of Jason Momoa, who carries the movie with his likable and relatable portrayal of Arthur, who struggles to balance his dual identity and his destiny as the king of Atlantis.
Aquaman 2 is a divisive and overstuffed sequel that may appeal to some fans of the genre, but may disappoint others who expect more coherence and originality from the DC cinematic universe. The movie is currently playing in theaters worldwide.
The Good
While Aquaman 2 has some glaring flaws, it’s not without merit. Here are some of the positives:
- Spectacular visual effects: The underwater scenes are simply breathtaking, transporting viewers to Atlantis and other aquatic kingdoms. The CGI creatures like the Karathen are extremely realistic.
- Thrilling action sequences: The movie has some exciting battles, from the opening submarine chase to the final fight for the trident. The action provides an adrenaline rush.
- Jason Momoa’s performance: As Arthur Curry/Aquaman, Momoa is effortlessly charismatic and cool. His wisecracks and swagger make him fun to watch.
- Patrick Wilson as Orm: Wilson chews scenery as Arthur’s vengeful half-brother. He and Momoa play well off each other.
- Fun world-building: We get to see more of Atlantis, learn about Atlantean mythology and history, and spend time in other underwater realms.
The Bad
Unfortunately, Aquaman 2 has got some weaknesses too that may bring the movie down:
- Messy, convoluted plot: There are too many subplots and villains. The quest for the trident, the war with Orm, Black Manta’s revenge, Arthur and Mera’s romance – it’s all overstuffed.
- Weak villain motivations: Orm, Manta, and others have flimsy reasons for their actions. This makes them less compelling antagonists.
- Poorly developed romance: Arthur and Mera’s relationship is bland. They lack chemistry and emotional connection.
- Amber Heard’s performance: Heard seems bored and disconnected as Mera. Her acting fails to convey the character’s fiery warrior spirit.
- CGI-heavy action: While spectacular, the constant CGI during action scenes is exhausting. More practical effects would’ve grounded the movie.
- Derivative story: Much of the plot feels recycled from other superhero films. Very little feels fresh or surprising.
Final Aquaman 2 Review
In the end, is Aquaman 2 worth seeing in theaters? Here’s a quick pro/con breakdown:
Pros
- Visually stunning
- Fun action set pieces
- Jason Momoa’s charm
Cons
- Messy, convoluted plot
- Weak villains and romance
- Overuse of CGI
- Recycled story beats
Verdict: Despite standout visuals and star power, Aquaman 2 buckles under the weight of an overstuffed plot, thinly sketched villains and relationships, and too much CGI. Passable for die-hard fans, but often disappointing.
Rating: 3/5*
Despite its issues, Aquaman 2 hints at potential for more compelling sequels if focused on a tighter story. The cast and visuals provide strong building blocks. Still, this overcrowded film will likely leave many viewers wishing they’d just rewatched the original. With more restraint, Aquaman 3 could be a superior underwater epic.
